A Look at Each Franchise's Best Ever Pick
Published on April 23rd, 2026 6:31 pm ESTWritten By: Dave Manuel
Thirty-two franchises, ninety years of the NFL Draft, one single selection per team that defined the course of the organization. From Tom Brady falling to pick 199 in 2000 to Bart Starr going in the 17th round at pick 200 in 1956, the draft is littered with stories of how one phone call changed a franchise forever. Below we walk team by team through all 32 organizations and pick the single greatest draft choice each one has ever made. Some calls are easy, some kept us up at night, and we flagged the hardest ones with Sports-King's Notes so you can push back. The full article follows.
Every NFL Team's Best Draft Pick Ever
Some of these are slam dunks. Jim Brown in Cleveland. Lawrence Taylor in New York. Tom Brady at 199. Nobody is fighting us on those.
Some are going to start arguments. The 49ers one in particular kept us up at night, and we flagged it with a note. Same for Baltimore (Lewis vs Ogden), Green Bay (Starr vs Rodgers), and Tampa (Brooks vs Sapp).
One pick per team. No cop-outs. No ties. Let's go.
NFC East
Aikman threw and Irvin caught, but Emmitt delivered. Three Super Bowls in four years doesn't happen without him.
Two Super Bowls. Ten Pro Bowls. He turned the Giants into the meanest defensive team of the decade and permanently altered how offenses had to protect the quarterback.
124 sacks in just eight Philly seasons. The supplemental draft is a technical distinction - he still counts, and he still wins.
Two Super Bowls. Seven Pro Bowls. Hall of Fame. Nobody has ever been faster for longer in the NFL.
NFC North
One Super Bowl (the 1985 monster), two rushing titles, and the toughest, most complete running back of his era. There's no argument here. Walter Payton is the Bears.
The Lions have had a rough franchise history, and Barry gave Detroit something to be proud of every single Sunday for a decade.
Aaron Rodgers at pick 24 in 2005 is a real argument and might be the more physically talented player. But Starr's combination of pick position, championships, and cultural weight is basically impossible to top. We are going with Starr.
He caught a rookie-record 17 touchdowns that year, changed how defenses had to cover the deep middle of the field, and finished with 156 career receiving touchdowns (second all-time behind Jerry Rice). The most physically gifted wide receiver who ever played, drafted in the 20s.
NFC South
Matt Ryan (2008, pick 3) is a solid argument. Julio Jones (2011, pick 6) too. Deion beats them both. Eight Pro Bowls, two Super Bowls, DPOY in 1994, Hall of Fame. Every touch of the ball was an electrical event.
Seven Pro Bowls in eight seasons. Five first-team All-Pros. Inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2026. When he was healthy, he was the best diagnostic linebacker in football and it wasn't particularly close.
115 career sacks, six Pro Bowls, a Super Bowl ring. At pick 51, Jackson is both elite value and elite production. Easy call.
Brooks edges Sapp here by a hair: 11 Pro Bowls to Sapp's 7, five first-team All-Pros, the 2002 DPOY award, and a Hall of Fame bust. That single 1995 weekend made the Buccaneers a decade-long contender.
NFC West
11 Pro Bowls. 17,492 career receiving yards (second all-time behind Jerry Rice). And the greatest postseason run by any wide receiver in the NFC Championship era - the 2008 playoffs remain statistically unreal. No other Cardinals pick in franchise history is close.
Six Pro Bowls, Hall of Fame, and the most visually iconic running back of the 1980s. The goggles and the upright running style are permanent franchise imagery for this team.
Joe Montana at pick 82 in 1979 might be the greatest draft pick in NFL history depending on how you define "great." Four Super Bowls. The best postseason resume of any quarterback who ever played. And he was a third-round pick, taken after three other quarterbacks that year. By almost any reasonable metric, he should be the answer here.
Here is why. Jerry Rice is the greatest wide receiver in football history, and it is not particularly close. 22,895 career receiving yards. 197 receiving touchdowns. Both records untouched in 2026 and likely permanent.
13 Pro Bowls. Three Super Bowls. One Super Bowl MVP. Rice was a 49er for 16 seasons and defined an era of San Francisco football that stretched beyond Montana. He caught passes from Young. He caught passes from Bono. The 49ers offense ran through Rice whether the quarterback was a Hall of Famer or a replacement-level guy.
Montana is the harder call. Rice is the bigger record book. Pick your poison. We picked Rice.
Steve Largent (1976, 4th round via Oilers trade) and Russell Wilson (2012, 3rd round, pick 75) are both legitimate arguments. Jones was elite-of-elite for over a decade, and that wins this one.
AFC East
There is no serious counter-argument here. Bruce Smith is Buffalo's greatest draft pick, full stop.
MVP as a second-year player in 1984. Nine Pro Bowls. No Super Bowl ring, something he will never stop hearing about, but an inner-circle Hall of Famer. Miami getting him at 27 is one of the most absurd wins in draft history.
The Patriots got him because six other quarterbacks were taken before him in the 2000 draft - Chad Pennington, Giovanni Carmazzi, Chris Redman, Tee Martin, Marc Bulger, and Spergon Wynn. The best draft pick in the history of American professional sports. Period.
Hall of Fame. The Jets' franchise identity is still shaped by him almost 60 years later. Revis is a close second, but Broadway Joe is the pick.
AFC North
Lewis was the identity of two different Super Bowl teams (2000 and 2012), a two-time Defensive Player of the Year, a Super Bowl XXXV MVP, and a 13-time Pro Bowler. Longevity plus peak plus cultural weight edges the tie.
The Bengals have had some tremendous picks over the years (Ken Anderson, Boomer Esiason, Chad Johnson, Joe Burrow) but Munoz was the gold standard. Widely considered the best left tackle ever to play the game, right alongside Anthony Munoz on the same list is just Anthony Munoz.
Greatest running back of all time by many measures. Cleveland has had rough drafts for 25 years but Jim Brown is a career-ender for the argument.
Mean Joe was the heart of the Steel Curtain, 10 Pro Bowls, four Super Bowls, two DPOYs. Everything the Steelers became in the 1970s started with the fourth pick of the 1969 draft.
AFC South
Watt is the best player the franchise has ever had by a wide margin and the primary reason Houston stayed relevant through multiple rebuilds. The Texans are a relatively young franchise, so the list of candidates is shorter, but it wouldn't matter - Watt wins in any era.
Johnny Unitas (1955, pick 102) is a historical footnote worth mentioning - he was actually drafted by Pittsburgh and cut before signing with the Colts as a free agent. Manning is the call for the franchise's best actual draft pick, and it's not close.
Fred Taylor (1998, pick 9) is a close second and a franchise legend in his own right. Boselli's peak was higher, and it was more impactful for what this expansion franchise was trying to build.
He played every position on the offensive line except center at an All-Pro level. Nineteen seasons in the trenches and 292 career starts. Position-flexible offensive line cornerstones who play two decades don't exist anymore.
AFC West
Then he built the 2015 Super Bowl-winning team as general manager. Terrell Davis at pick 196 in 1995 is one of the great value steals in NFL history, but Elway is the identity of the Denver Broncos.
Derrick Thomas and Tony Gonzalez are both Hall of Famers and franchise icons, but Mahomes has already eclipsed both in terms of hardware at age 30. He's not done yet either.
Tim Brown (1988, pick 6) is the other serious option. Allen's MVP season and Super Bowl XVIII MVP performance (191 rushing yards, 74-yard TD run) give him the edge.
The Chargers have had plenty of great players come through the draft over the years (Junior Seau, Kellen Winslow, Dan Fouts, Philip Rivers) but LaDainian Tomlinson is the peak of the franchise.
Your favorite team isn't listed the way you think it should be? Good. That means you care. A few we sweated over: Montana vs Rice in SF. Lewis vs Ogden in Baltimore. Starr vs Rodgers in Green Bay. Brooks vs Sapp in Tampa. Smith vs Staubach in Dallas.
Draft weekend is coming. See you at the podium.