Baseball

The Climb to 75 Percent

By Dave ManuelPublished November 9th, 2026

Every winter a few hundred baseball writers decide who goes into the Hall of Fame, and the bar is high: 75% of the ballots. Some players clear it on the first try. Others spend a decade climbing, and some never get there. I wanted to see what the climb really looks like, so I went through every writers' ballot since 1966 and lined up this year's candidates against everyone who came before them.


BASEBALL | THE SPORTS-KING RECORD BOOK
A player needs 75% of the writers' votes to get into Cooperstown, and he has ten tries to get there. Here is how every candidate since 1966 made the climb or fell short, and where this year's ballot stands.
By Dave - every BBWAA ballot from 1966 to 2026, checked vote by vote

What this tracks: the final result of every writers' ballot since 1966 and each candidate's climb from year to year. It is not a live count of the ballots voters publish before the 2027 announcement.

111 of 115Players who reached 50% with the writers and have finished their time on the ballot who are now in the Hall of Fame (96.5%).
34 of 34Candidates who reached 60% to just under 75% within their first six years who were later elected by the writers.
2 votesThe closest anyone has come and missed: Craig Biggio in 2014 and Nellie Fox in 1985.
7.3%Andruw Jones's share in his first year, 2018. He was elected in 2026.

The Climb to 75%

Every candidate on the 2027 ballot who was on last year's ballot is drawn here year by year, with the two players the writers elected last January, Carlos Beltrán and Andruw Jones, as dashed green lines for comparison. Pick a name to pick out his line.

The Climb to 75%
VOTE SHARE BY YEAR ON THE BALLOT, 2027 HOLDOVERS AND THE 2026 ELECTEES
0%25%50%75%100%75% NEEDED12345678910YEAR ON THE BALLOTC. Utley 59.1%A. Pettitte 48.5%F. Hernández 46.1%A. Rodriguez 40.0%B. Abreu 30.8%J. Rollins 25.4%C. Hamels 23.8%D. Pedroia 20.7%M. Buehrle 20.0%O. Vizquel 18.4%D. Wright 14.8%F. Rodríguez 11.8%T. Hunter 8.7%C. Beltrán 84.2%A. Jones 78.4%0%25%50%75%100%75% NEEDED12345678910YEAR ON THE BALLOT
On the 2027 ballotElected in 202675% line

Jones is the best reason not to read too much into a low start. He started at 7.3% in 2018, was still under 20% in his third year, and got in with 78.4% in his ninth. Beltrán went 46.5%, 57.1%, 70.3% and then 84.2%. Of this year's holdovers, Chase Utley is closest at 59.1%. His 19.3-point gain last January was bigger than any single-year gain Beltrán made on his way in.

The 2027 Ballot at a Glance

As of November 9, 2026. The official 2027 ballot is released on November 16, 2026. Voting closes at the end of December, the results are announced on January 19, 2027, and the class is inducted in Cooperstown on July 25, 2027.

Thirteen players return from last year. Each bar is his share last January; the red mark is 75%. Omar Vizquel is in his 10th and final year. Andy Pettitte is in his 9th.

Where the Holdovers Stand
2026 VOTE SHARE AND YEAR ON THE 2027 BALLOT
Chase Utley59.1% | year 4 of 10Andy Pettitte48.5% | year 9 of 10Félix Hernández46.1% | year 3 of 10Alex Rodriguez40.0% | year 6 of 10Bobby Abreu30.8% | year 8 of 10Jimmy Rollins25.4% | year 6 of 10Cole Hamels23.8% | year 2 of 10Dustin Pedroia20.7% | year 3 of 10Mark Buehrle20.0% | year 7 of 10Omar Vizquel18.4% | year 10 of 10David Wright14.8% | year 4 of 10Francisco Rodríguez11.8% | year 5 of 10Torii Hunter8.7% | year 7 of 10C. Utley59.1% | year 4A. Pettitte48.5% | year 9F. Hernández46.1% | year 3A. Rodriguez40.0% | year 6B. Abreu30.8% | year 8J. Rollins25.4% | year 6C. Hamels23.8% | year 2D. Pedroia20.7% | year 3M. Buehrle20.0% | year 7O. Vizquel18.4% | year 10D. Wright14.8% | year 4F. Rodríguez11.8% | year 5T. Hunter8.7% | year 7

The new names come from players whose last season was 2021. Buster Posey leads the group. These are the expected first-timers; the writers' screening committee decides who makes the printed ballot.

PLAYERPOSCAREERKEY NUMBERS
Buster PoseyC2009-2021.302, 1,500 hits, 2012 NL MVP, 2010 NL Rookie of the Year, 7 All-Star Games, 3 World Series titles
Jon LesterSP2006-2021200-117, 3.66 ERA, 2,488 strikeouts, 3 World Series titles
Brett GardnerOF2008-20211,470 hits, 274 steals, 1 Gold Glove, 2009 World Series
Ryan Zimmerman3B/1B2005-20211,846 hits, 284 HR, 2019 World Series
Kyle Seager3B2011-20211,395 hits, 242 HR, 1 Gold Glove
Jay BruceRF2008-2021319 HR, 951 RBI, 3 All-Star Games
Jake ArrietaSP2010-2021115-93, 2015 NL Cy Young, 2016 World Series
Jordan ZimmermannSP2009-202195-91, 2 All-Star Games
Andrew MillerRP2006-20212016 ALCS MVP, 2 All-Star Games

A separate vote comes first. The Contemporary Era committee, which looks at managers, executives and umpires, meets on December 6, 2026. Its ballot has managers Dusty Baker, Bruce Bochy, Joe Maddon and Lou Piniella and executives Sandy Alderson, Brian Sabean, Ted Turner and Bill White. A candidate needs 12 of the 16 votes.

The Path to 75% Checker

Pick a 2027 candidate, or type in any share and year on the ballot. The checker finds every past candidate who stood within five points of that share at the same stage, and shows how many of them the writers went on to elect, and which of the others a committee elected later. For this year's candidates it uses their last completed ballot: for Chase Utley that is 59.1% in his 3rd year, 2026.

A note on how to read it: stages are grouped as year 1, years 2 and 3, years 4 to 6, years 7 to 9 and year 10 or later, because there are only so many candidates at any one share in any one year. Before 2015 players could stay on the ballot for 15 years, so some of the older names had more time than today's candidates get.

The 50% Rule

The old saying is that anyone who reaches 50% with the writers ends up in the Hall of Fame. It is very nearly true. Since 1966, 117 players have reached 50% on a writers' ballot. Two are still on it. Of the other 115, the writers elected 104 and a committee elected 7 more, which makes 111 of 115.

Everyone Who Reached 50%
EACH SQUARE IS ONE PLAYER, IN THE ORDER THEY FIRST TOPPED 50%
Elected by the writersElected by a committeeNot electedStill on the ballot

Tap a square for the player.

The four exceptions are Curt Schilling, who peaked at 71.1%, the highest share of any player never elected, and Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and Gary Sheffield. All four used up their years with the writers. Bonds, Clemens and Sheffield each got fewer than five of the 16 votes from the Contemporary Era committee in December 2025, which elected Jeff Kent instead.

The seven committee picks are Enos Slaughter, Jim Bunning, Nellie Fox, Orlando Cepeda, Jack Morris, Lee Smith and Gil Hodges. Until Schilling, Bonds, Clemens and Sheffield, every 50% player the writers passed over was later elected by a committee.

The stronger version of the rule is about timing. Every candidate who reached somewhere between 60% and just under 75% within his first six years on the ballot was later elected by the writers: 34 of 34. (Players who went straight past 75% are not counted here; they were elected on the spot.)

The Closest Calls

The line is 75%, rounded up to the next whole vote. These are the nearest misses since 1966.

YEARPLAYERSHAREVOTES SHORTWHAT HAPPENED NEXT
2014Craig Biggio74.8%2Elected the next year by the writers
1985Nellie Fox74.7%2His 15th and last year; elected by the Veterans Committee in 1997
1988Jim Bunning74.2%4Elected by the Veterans Committee in 1996
1986Billy Williams74.1%4Elected the next year by the writers
2010Bert Blyleven74.2%5Elected the next year by the writers
2017Trevor Hoffman74.0%5Elected the next year by the writers
2024Billy Wagner73.8%5Elected the next year, in his 10th and final year
2010Roberto Alomar73.7%8Elected the next year, in his 2nd year
1994Orlando Cepeda73.5%7His 15th and last year; elected by the Veterans Committee in 1999

The other side of the line has its own stories. Fergie Jenkins in 1991 and Ralph Kiner in 1975 both made it with a single vote to spare, and Kiner did it in his final year.

The Biggest One-Year Jumps

Support usually builds slowly, but not always. These are the ten biggest gains from one ballot to the next since 1966. Félix Hernández's jump from 20.6% to 46.1% last January ties Luis Aparicio's for the biggest of all, and Andy Pettitte added 20.6 points in the same vote.

The Biggest One-Year Jumps
VOTE SHARE ONE YEAR TO THE NEXT, TOP 10 SINCE 1966
0%25%50%75%100%Luis Aparicio, 1982-83+25.5Félix Hernández, 2025-26+25.5Barry Larkin, 2011-12+24.3Gil Hodges, 1969-70+24.2Nellie Fox, 1975-76+23.8Hal Newhouser, 1974-75+22.8Jim Rice, 1999-00+22.1Larry Walker, 2019-20+22.0Don Drysdale, 1976-77+22.0Vladimir Guerrero, 2017-18+21.20%25%50%75%100%L. Aparicio 83+25.5F. Hernández 26+25.5B. Larkin 12+24.3G. Hodges 70+24.2N. Fox 76+23.8H. Newhouser 75+22.8J. Rice 00+22.1L. Walker 20+22.0D. Drysdale 77+22.0V. Guerrero 18+21.2
Previous yearNext year

Some climbs ran out of road. Seven players since 1966 were elected by the writers in their final year:

YEARPLAYERFINAL YEARRESULT
1967Red Ruffing15thElected in a runoff after 72.6% on the main ballot
1975Ralph Kiner13th75.4%, one vote to spare
2009Jim Rice15th76.4%
2017Tim Raines10th86.0%
2019Edgar Martínez10th85.4%
2020Larry Walker10th76.6%
2025Billy Wagner10th82.5%

Billy Wagner is the most recent. He missed by five votes in 2024 and got 82.5% in 2025, his last chance.

First Ballot or Long Wait

Of the 104 players the writers have elected since 1966, 55 got in on the first ballot. Each square below is one of the 104, placed by the year on the ballot in which he was elected. Tap one for the name.

First Ballot or Long Wait
PLAYERS ELECTED BY THE WRITERS SINCE 1966, BY YEAR ON THE BALLOT
123456789101112131415YEAR ON THE BALLOT WHEN ELECTED123456789101112131415YEAR ON THE BALLOT WHEN ELECTED
First ballotLater years

Tap a square for the player.

The top of the first-ballot list is Mariano Rivera, the only unanimous pick at 100% in 2019, followed by Derek Jeter and Ichiro Suzuki, who each finished one vote short. At the other end, 26 players needed six years or more. Andruw Jones, who needed nine, put it simply on the day: "It was very close for me to be off the ballot."

Every Candidate Who Reached 50%

All 117 players who reached 50% on a writers' ballot since 1966. Click a column heading to sort. For players who were already on the ballot before 1966, years on the ballot count their earlier years too.

PLAYERFIRST OVER 50%PEAKYEARS ON BALLOTHOW IT ENDED
Henry Aaron198297.8%1Writers, 1982
Roberto Alomar201090.0%2Writers, 2011
Luis Aparicio198384.6%6Writers, 1984
Jeff Bagwell201286.2%7Writers, 2017
Ernie Banks197783.8%1Writers, 1977
Carlos Beltrán202484.2%4Writers, 2026
Adrian Beltré202495.1%1Writers, 2024
Johnny Bench198996.4%1Writers, 1989
Yogi Berra197185.6%2Writers, 1972
Craig Biggio201382.7%3Writers, 2015
Bert Blyleven200679.7%14Writers, 2011
Wade Boggs200591.9%1Writers, 2005
Barry Bonds201766.0%10Not elected
Lou Boudreau196877.3%10Writers, 1970
George Brett199998.2%1Writers, 1999
Lou Brock198579.7%1Writers, 1985
Jim Bunning198574.2%15Veterans Committee, 1996
Roy Campanella196679.4%5Writers, 1969
Rod Carew199190.5%1Writers, 1991
Steve Carlton199495.6%1Writers, 1994
Gary Carter200178.0%6Writers, 2003
Orlando Cepeda199273.5%15Veterans Committee, 1999
Roger Clemens201765.2%10Not elected
Andre Dawson200377.9%9Writers, 2010
Don Drysdale197778.4%10Writers, 1984
Dennis Eckersley200483.2%1Writers, 2004
Rollie Fingers199181.2%2Writers, 1992
Carlton Fisk199979.6%2Writers, 2000
Whitey Ford197377.8%2Writers, 1974
Nellie Fox198474.7%15Veterans Committee, 1997
Bob Gibson198184.0%1Writers, 1981
Tom Glavine201491.9%1Writers, 2014
Rich Gossage200585.8%9Writers, 2008
Vladimir Guerrero201792.9%2Writers, 2018
Tony Gwynn200797.6%1Writers, 2007
Roy Halladay201985.4%1Writers, 2019
Todd Helton202279.7%6Writers, 2024
Rickey Henderson200994.8%1Writers, 2009
Gil Hodges197163.4%15Golden Days Era Committee, 2022
Trevor Hoffman201679.9%3Writers, 2018
Catfish Hunter198576.3%3Writers, 1987
Reggie Jackson199393.6%1Writers, 1993
Fergie Jenkins198975.4%3Writers, 1991
Derek Jeter202099.7%1Writers, 2020
Randy Johnson201597.3%1Writers, 2015
Andruw Jones202378.4%9Writers, 2026
Chipper Jones201897.2%1Writers, 2018
Cal Ripken Jr.200798.5%1Writers, 2007
Ken Griffey Jr.201699.3%1Writers, 2016
Al Kaline198088.3%1Writers, 1980
Harmon Killebrew198183.1%4Writers, 1984
Ralph Kiner197075.4%13Writers, 1975
Sandy Koufax197286.9%1Writers, 1972
Barry Larkin201086.4%3Writers, 2012
Bob Lemon197478.6%12Writers, 1976
Greg Maddux201497.2%1Writers, 2014
Mickey Mantle197488.2%1Writers, 1974
Juan Marichal198183.7%3Writers, 1983
Edgar Martínez201785.4%10Writers, 2019
Pedro Martínez201591.1%1Writers, 2015
Eddie Mathews197779.4%5Writers, 1978
Joe Mauer202476.1%1Writers, 2024
Willie Mays197994.7%1Writers, 1979
Willie McCovey198681.4%1Writers, 1986
Joe Medwick196684.8%9Writers, 1968
Paul Molitor200485.2%1Writers, 2004
Joe Morgan199081.8%1Writers, 1990
Jack Morris201067.7%15Modern Baseball Era Committee, 2018
Eddie Murray200385.3%1Writers, 2003
Stan Musial196993.2%1Writers, 1969
Mike Mussina201776.7%6Writers, 2019
Phil Niekro199380.3%5Writers, 1997
David Ortiz202277.9%1Writers, 2022
Jim Palmer199092.6%1Writers, 1990
Gaylord Perry198977.2%3Writers, 1991
Mike Piazza201383.0%4Writers, 2016
Kirby Puckett200182.1%1Writers, 2001
Tony Pérez199277.2%9Writers, 2000
Tim Raines201386.0%10Writers, 2017
Jim Rice200076.4%15Writers, 2009
Mariano Rivera2019100.0%1Writers, 2019
Robin Roberts197386.9%4Writers, 1976
Frank Robinson198289.2%1Writers, 1982
Brooks Robinson198392.0%1Writers, 1983
Iván Rodríguez201776.0%1Writers, 2017
Scott Rolen202176.3%6Writers, 2023
Red Ruffing196672.6%15Writers, 1967
Nolan Ryan199998.8%1Writers, 1999
CC Sabathia202586.8%1Writers, 2025
Ryne Sandberg200476.2%3Writers, 2005
Curt Schilling201671.1%10Not elected
Mike Schmidt199596.5%1Writers, 1995
Tom Seaver199298.8%1Writers, 1992
Gary Sheffield202363.9%10Not elected
Enos Slaughter197668.9%14Veterans Committee, 1985
Ozzie Smith200291.7%1Writers, 2002
Lee Smith201250.6%15Today's Game Era Committee, 2019
John Smoltz201582.9%1Writers, 2015
Duke Snider197786.5%11Writers, 1980
Warren Spahn197383.2%1Writers, 1973
Willie Stargell198882.4%1Writers, 1988
Bruce Sutter200276.9%13Writers, 2006
Don Sutton199481.6%5Writers, 1998
Ichiro Suzuki202599.7%1Writers, 2025
Frank Thomas201483.7%1Writers, 2014
Jim Thome201889.8%1Writers, 2018
Chase Utley202659.1%3On the 2027 ballot
Omar Vizquel202052.6%9On the 2027 ballot
Billy Wagner202282.5%10Writers, 2025
Larry Walker201976.6%10Writers, 2020
Hoyt Wilhelm198083.8%8Writers, 1985
Ted Williams196693.4%1Writers, 1966
Billy Williams198485.7%6Writers, 1987
Dave Winfield200184.5%1Writers, 2001
Early Wynn197176.0%4Writers, 1972
Carl Yastrzemski198994.6%1Writers, 1989
Robin Yount199977.5%1Writers, 1999

How this was put together. Every BBWAA ballot from 1966 to 2026 was taken from Baseball-Reference's yearly voting pages and checked row by row: each share was recomputed from votes and ballots cast, and every year's votes needed equals 75% of the ballots, rounded up. The 2026 results were also checked against the BBWAA and MLB.com, and every holdover's year-by-year share against Wikipedia's balloting pages. Shares under 5% are not included, since a player below 5% drops off the ballot. Red Ruffing's 1967 election came in a runoff and is counted as an election by the writers; Roberto Clemente's 1973 special election is not included. Committee elections for every candidate come from the Hall of Fame's member list and Baseball-Reference's inductee list. First-timer career numbers are from Baseball-Reference.

Download the data: every BBWAA vote share of 5% or more, 1966 to 2026 (CSV).

Sources: Baseball-Reference BBWAA voting pages (one per year, 1966 to 2026) and its inductee list; the National Baseball Hall of Fame; the BBWAA; MLB.com; the Associated Press on the December 2025 committee vote; Wikipedia's list of Hall of Fame members for committee elections; the Andruw Jones quote from WSB-TV, January 21, 2026.

18+. Betting involves risk. Nothing here is a prediction or financial advice. Please gamble responsibly.

More from Sports-King

Archive →